While there are tons of Peanut Butter Cookie recipes, we chose to stay close to the original Peanut Butter Cookie recipe published in 1916 by George Washington Carver. We use freshly ground peanuts grown locally in Eastern North Carolina and forego the fork marks that weren’t introduced until the 1930s.
Our cookies (and all of our products) are handmade in small batches with love in our store in Jamesville, NC.
• No preservatives
• All-Natural Ingredients
If you’re looking to buy Peanut Butter Cookies and have them delivered to your door (or as a gift to loved ones), we suggest you buy Mackeys Ferry Peanuts’ truly old-fashioned, small-batch Peanut Butter Cookies because we take great care in the packaging and shipping process so that your cookies arrive quickly and intact.